Art is the telling of truth and is the only available method for the telling of certain truths.
Zimbabwe achieved its independence in 1980 after seventeen years of a civil war, a war in which -- and estimates vary from 30, 000 to 70, 000 -- men, women and children left the country to live in often appalling conditions in Mozambique and Zambia, hoping to return as guerrillas to fight against a white regime of 250,000 people with all the advantages of a conventional army and airforce and one which mustered all its men into the war. Both sides believed they had right on their side, both used propaganda to espouse their cause, and both sides had to engender a hatred of the opposing side because you cannot kill another human being unless he or she is perceived as your "enemy." There was no one in Zimbabwe whose lives were not disrupted and changed by the war, no one who did not suffer its psychological consequences and no one who did not lose either friends or family.
The war and all the terrible suffering that it engendered was unnecessary. Selfishness, bigotry, insularity, arrogance, greed and intransigence on the part of white leaders, men who had the power and did not relinquish control, men who were elected by a tiny minority of the population and who used fear as a means of social control, misused their authority and caused a situation in which the only recourse left to the black population was through the barrel of a gun. However, Zanla and Zipra, the two guerrilla armies suffered a great deal of internal conflict, dissension was not tolerated, there was guerrilla on guerrilla violence as well as hunger, rape, rough punishment including beating and executions of both people within the army and of the civilian population.
In 1980 Zimbabwe achieved the hard-won freedom its people had for which its people so long fought. Robert Mugabe became the Prime Minister and astonishingly offered a hand of reconciliation and friendship. Nonetheless many whites, deeply embittered and unable to either accept defeat or adjust to the new situation, left the country. Peace, democracy, a new constitution, a black government, a socialist ideology free education and health for all were among many of the principles that offered hope to the citizens of the new Zimbabwe. No one wanted to discuss the atrocities committed by both sides. Another consequence of war, a civil war in particular, is fear.
For the first five or six years after independence Zimbabwean authors who write in English published little of any real literary worth. Why? I don't know -- all I can offer are a few suggestions.
One, it was a time of great hope, great promise, great expectation and there are not many great books which have been forged out of joy: jubilation can lead to purple-patched excess.
Two, the struggle for independence was seen as an heroic struggle against great odds. Books such as The Struggle for Zimbabwe: the Chimurenga War by David Martin and Phyllis Johnson, Guns and Rain, Guerrillas and Spirit Mediums in Zimbabwe, by David Lan and Peasant Consciousness and Guerrilla War by Terence Ranger tended to portray it in this light.
Three, it was a period of adjustment, of quiet grief, of mourning, of pain. As Alexander Kanengoni says in his forthcoming novel, Echoing Silences,
But soon, [Munashe's] indifference was overshadowed by parents who thronged the assembly point looking for their children. They arrived throughout the day: in the morning, afternoon and evening ... They came by bus, by car and on foot. And it was not long before [he] noticed that beneath their outward happiness, behind their inebriated singing as the buses and lorries rolled into the assembly point, beneath their wild embraces as fighters met their people, they all looked the same: anxious, uncertain, afraid. It showed in the way their eyes searched through the guerrilla ranks. It showed in their voices as they talked to the guerrillas about what a burden the war was now that it was over and they would soon be free. They did not ask directly about the whereabouts of their own sons and daughters ... Instead they asked whether the guerrillas at Dzapasi were the only ones left after the long war. Even as they asked the question, one could detect the panic in their eyes. To them, it was clear that victory and independence would be meaningless if their own children did not return home ... (forthcoming)
Yvonne Vera, in several short stories in her collection, Why Don't you Carve Other Animals, portrays the intensely personal and peculiar disillusionment with the actuality of independence; the disparity between the huge hope and expectation in the minds of individuals and the reality of the celebrations:
The man kept one arm around the woman while with the other he held a bottle of cold beer. He had the television on, and insisted that he would watch the Independence celebrations first ... First there was traditional dancing in the middle of the stadium. The woman withdrew into the safe place within her mind and watched the pictures go by on the screen. The new Prime Minister made a long speech ...The woman saw the Prince sitting quietly in his spotless white clothing. The said his mother could not come. ... the man watching the screen went to the kitchen for another beer. He was going to celebrate Independence properly: with cold beer and a woman. Now it was ten minutes to midnight. She must take her clothes off. ... The man pushed the woman on to the floor. He was going into the new era in style and triumph. She opened her legs. It was midnight and the new flag went up ... When he was through he sent her home. When he awoke he preferred [to have] the whole house to himself. ('Independence Day')
Four, peace was too precious, hope for a black government too great, reconciliation too precarious, war and the memory of war too painful for anyone to want to immediately probe the complexities of war, the pain and the grief.
Five, in the early years after independence there was, as one writer told me, an expectation that Zimbabwean authors would write books that proclaimed the socialist message; didactic novels. Naturally for many this expectation proved more of an inhibition than an inducement to write.
Six, the historical tensions, rivalry and bitterness between Zanu and Zapu, Zanla and Zipra, the Shona and the Ndebele, led to the experience of Gukurahundi in Matabeleland when it is conservatively estimated that the Fifth Brigade (a unit of men especially trained by the Koreans) killed three thousand people in Matabeleland between 1981 and 1985: many thousands more were beaten, tortured and their villages burnt down. The government was silent on the issue. People knew its power. They knew it expected absolute, uncritical, unswerving loyalty. It was a victorious government born of the fruits of of an heroic struggle.